Audio

Conversations

Jaamva chalo ji

Photography

User login

Reply to comment

The Asawari Mk 2

This project is currently work in progress.

The Asawari Mk II was conceived of as soon as the first Asawari showed signs that it would be a usable speaker. Since then, the Mk II has moved from concept to enclosure construction.

The differences between the original and the Mk II are as follows:

  • The original was constructed entirely out of 20mm marine ply, whereas the Mk II has a shell made of MDF (including front and rear baffles) and internal bracing of very good quality 20mm commercial ply.
  • The original used a Peerless India TG25 tweeter, while the Mk II is designed to use a North Creek D25-06 silk dome tweeter.
  • The front baffle is a shade wider in the Mk II (if I recall correctly, about 2cm).
  • The separate acoustically isolated crossover chamber of the original has now been discarded in the interests of reducing overall external volume. The original Asawari was rather large, specially in the depth dimension.
  • The internal acoustic volume of the Mk II is a shade smaller (perhaps 5%) than the original. This, coupled with the elimination of a separate crossover chamber has resulted in significant reduction of overall size.
  • Cosmetic changes: the base has been reduced in size to have exactly the same footprint as the body. In the original, the base projected out on all sides below the body. Also, the glass top is now 6mm, not 12mm thick.

The midbass driver remains the same. The enclosure is still a floor-stander, and at first glance, someone who has seen the original Asawari will probably mistake the Mk II for the original, specially from the front. From the side, the reduced depth is unmistakable.

The tweeter has been replaced primarily to allow me to try a lower crossover point. The North D25 will happily cross over at 1,600Hz, fourth order, and I am intending to try an Fc of 1,600-1,800Hz. I wish to see whether the sound of the midbass driver changes if I restrict its reach into the higher frequencies. The North D25 is (was) a very affordable tweeter. IIRC, it cost me less than $20 each, and John "Zaph" Krutke has reviewed it and found it to be quite a decent performer. At that price, I doubt there is (was) any tweeter which performed so well and also allowed such a low Fc. At $20, its price was comparable to the TG25 from Peerless India.

One sad side-effect of this is that no one else will be able to make the Asawari Mk II after I publish my full article. North Creek has stopped selling drivers though they still make them. These drivers are only available as part of their kits.

If I had to replace the D25 with another driver which delivered excellent performance for a low price, probably the next driver I would look at would be the Seas TBFC/G and TDFC models. They cost less than $40 each, I believe.

In the meantime, anyone, specially in India, wantingto build the Mk II can probably do so by getting hold of the original TG25 Al-dome tweeter and just constructing the enclosure of the Mk II with the crossover of the original. In that case, they will get some of the benefits of the Mk II, e.g. smaller enclosure size, without having to worry about the North D25.

 Next: Enclosure

Reply

CAPTCHA
This question is to prevent automated bot-driven submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.